Home » Digitisation » Honest DigMyPics vs Legacy Box 2024 Review: Who Wins?

Honest DigMyPics vs Legacy Box 2024 Review: Who Wins?

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between DigMyPics vs Legacy Box, the better digitalization service for most people is Legacybox. However, the best in category is iMemories.

Introduction to Our DigMyPics vs Legacy Box Comparison

Welcome to our comparison review of DigMyPics vs Legacy Box!

Image and file conversion services are not made equal and some are definitely better than others. So, today’s DigMyPics vs Legacy Box comparison review will tell the tale of the tape and show which of these two offers the better service.

Quick Comparison Table

Here's a comparison table between Digmypics and Legacybox. Note: Prices are subject to change over time. Please click the links to check for current pricing.

ServicesPhoto, slide, negative, and video conversionPhoto, film, video, and audio conversion
PricingVaries based on services and quantityVaries based on services and quantity
Online PlatformYesYes
ShippingShipping fee appliesShipping kit provided for secure shipping
Turnaround TimeVaries based on services and quantityVaries based on services and quantity
QualityHigh-quality digital conversionHigh-quality digital conversion
Additional FeaturesOnline preview and orderingOnline order tracking and status updates
Storage OptionsDVD, USB, and online storage options availableDVD, USB, and online storage options available
Customer SupportEmail, phone, and live chat support availableEmail and phone support available
Guarantee100% satisfaction guaranteeSatisfaction guarantee with refund or rework option
CostCheck Current PricingCheck Current Pricing

Overview: What are DigMyPics vs Legacy Box?

Legacybox is a service that digitizes different forms of analog media. By “analog,” we’re talking about old-school VHS and Betamax cassettes, film negatives, Super 8 film footage, and even audio recordings on cassette or vinyl.

digmypics vs legacy box review

DigMyPics is an online business that has been around since 2002. Located in Gilbert, AZ, the company specializes in converting various visual media into digital files. That said, the service can handle both audio and video conversions and is one of the few companies that offers reel to reel / cassette to file audio conversion.

digmypics reviews 2
image © 2024. all rights reserved.



We can’t help but feel that DigMyPics tends to complicate its process for customers. You’re encouraged to gather all the stuff you want to convert together, then check their site for a cost estimate. In terms of shipping, you can’t use just any courier service to ship your files over: you need to use their courier of choice.

digmypics reviews 7


For Legacybox, it’s a fairly straightforward experience. You order a box from the service, then fill it up with the materials you want converted into digital files. A step-by-step guide comes with the box, and that includes shipping instructions. Pack, ship, and you get your files sent back in a secure thumb drive, a set of DVDs, or a secure download link that lets you drop everything into Google Drive.

legacybox imemories vs legacybox 2

Winner – Legacybox! This phase of DigMyPics vs Legacy box we’re giving to Legacybox as it makes things so easy for clients. Also, you can use your courier of preference.



While DigMyPics claims that they can do same-day conversion and you can get a link to the converted files within a very short time period, we recommend that you take this with a grain of salt. Also, the service’s downloader for desktop is slow, tends to stop, and restarts completely in the event of a power failure. Not very reliable, if you ask us.

digmypics reviews 8
image © 2024. all rights reserved.


The main issue with Legacybox is that it takes 10 to 12 weeks before you get your digital files. But Legacybox’s team of imaging professionals ensures that all analog media sent are re-recorded and remastered for clarity and quality. That said, it may take a while, but you know your memories are in good hands.

legacybox imemories vs legacybox 3

Winner – Legacybox! Between DigMyPics vs Legacy Box in terms of reliability, Legacybox gets the job done – and does it well.



  • Photo Keeper service with the following features:
    • Video conversion from several tape formats;
    • Film conversion from 8mm to 16mm;
    • Multiple format photo conversion; and
    • Audio conversion.
digmypics reviews 1
image © 2024. all rights reserved.


  • Submission Box
    • Varying capacity from two to 40 analog materials for digital conversion;
    • How-to guide;
    • Security barcodes for safe submission; and
    • Pre-printed shipping label
  • Output Formats
    • Link access to cloud with unlimited downloads and a 90-day secure backup;
    • Secured thumb drive; and
    • Burning to standard DVD.
legacybox imemories vs legacybox 3

Winner – Legacybox! Give it to Legacybox – you know what to send them, you know what you’re getting.

Value for Money


Our issue with DigMyPics? They charge you by the piece and their pricing structure is quite complicated. While standard photo conversion starts at $0.49 per item, converting audiovisual files are priced depending on format – and the management will get back to you on that.

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

To be fair, you can get a full refund if you file a complaint within 21 days of delivery.

Be sure to get their service or avail of customer support only via their official website.


Legacybox standard digitization packages start from at the following prices. Regardless of output format, digitization charges are set at $19.99.

legacybox imemories vs legacybox pricing

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

While there are Legacybox kits offered on Amazon, we recommend that you get the service only through the official website to ensure quality service and output.

Also, if you aren’t happy with the service, you can return the output and file for a refund within 30 days upon receipt of the finished product.

Winner – Legacybox! No question for this round in DigMyPics vs Legacy Box, Legacybox makes its pricing schema clear for its customers.

User Reviews


Unfortunately, DigMyPics doesn’t have the most savory reputation with customers. For the most part, people have complained about the overall quality of the finished product, including badly done color correction, discoloration of images scanned from slides, and warbling audio remasters. Likewise, customer assistance is neither friendly nor helpful.


Legacybox currently has a 3.9-stars rating on Trustpilot with five-star reviews making up 52% of the 616 currently on record. Most of those who reviewed the service appreciated the clear submission instructions, secure delivery, and satisfying output.

image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Winner – Legacybox! No question – this lap in our DigMyPics vs Legacy Box comparison goes to Legacybox.

Conclusion and Recommendations to our DigMyPics vs Legacy Box Comparison

Now to wrap up our DigMyPics vs Legacy Box comparison;

Who is DigMyPics best for?

This service works for those for whom quality is not an issue.

Who is Legacybox best for?

Legacybox works best for those who want quality digitization services but are willing to wait.

DigMyPics vs Legacybox Alternatives

If you’re looking for a state of the art digitization service, we recommend you give iMemories a try.

CompanyServices OfferedUnique FeaturesPrice Range
🏆 iMemoriesTapes, film, photos, slidesCloud storage, online sharing$$-$$$
LegacyboxVHS, film, photosEasy kits, bulk discounts$$-$$$
YesVideoVHS tapes, camcorder tapes, film reels, slidesOnline viewing and sharing$$
EverPresentVideo tapes, movie films, photos, slides, audioCustom editing, private consultations$$$
SouthtreeSimilar to LegacyboxFrequent promotions$$-$$$
ScanCafePhotos, slides, negatives, video tapesHigh-resolution, manual color correction$$-$$$
ScanMyPhotosPhotos, slides, film reelsFast service, bulk pricing$-$$
Digital MemoriesFilm, photos, slides, audioCustom storage solutions$$-$$$
ScanDigitalAll types of mediaCareful handling of media, comprehensive services$$-$$$
Memory FortressPhotos, videos, audio tapesQuick turnaround, straightforward pricing$-$$

DigMyPics vs Legacybox Comparison Final Word

Legacybox gets out vote as the winner of our DigmyPics vs Legacybox comparison as it ticks the boxes in terms of service quality, product quality, and reliability.

However, there are other more robust alternatives like iMemories that we highly recommend and you should seriously consider.

Please note that to get authentic, high-quality products, we recommend that you avail of iMemories only from their official website. You may also get great discounts for multiple purchases. Beware of purchasing from marketplace sites claiming to be resellers so to avoid issues with refunds and returns in the future!


Do either of these services return my original materials?

Yes, both companies will send back original tapes, prints, and negatives to owners once a service has been delivered.

How do I ship stuff to Legacybox?

You order the Legacybox Kit from the original website – price dependent on the number of materials submitted – and use the enclosed barcodes and shipping label to send them your stuff.

If you've read all the way through this DigMyPics vs Legacy Box comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed all these products in detail, feel free to check them out;


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.