Home » Digitisation » Straightforward iMemories vs LegacyBox 2024 Comparison: Who Wins?

Straightforward iMemories vs LegacyBox 2024 Comparison: Who Wins?

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between iMemories vs LegacyBox, the better digitalization service for most people is iMemories.

Introduction to our iMemories vs Legacybox Comparison

You're reading our iMemories vs LegacyBox comparison review!

File digitization is something that has enabled many people to preserve precious memories that would have been lost due to physical deterioration and consequent wear and tear. But with all the digitization services currently available, which ones can help preserve your old photos, home movies, and voice recordings in the best manner possible? That’s what we’re finding out in today’s iMemories vs Legacybox comparison.

Quick Comparison Table

Note: Prices are subject to change over time. Please click the links to check for current pricing.

Feature🏆 iMemories (My Pick!)LegacyBox
Service TypePhoto & Video DigitizationPhoto, Video & Audio Digitization
Digitization ProcessMail-in service, digitizes to cloudMail-in service, digitizes to DVDs, CDs, or digital files
Formats AcceptedPhotos, Negatives, Slides, Video Tapes, Movie FilmsPhotos, Negatives, Slides, Video Tapes, Movie Films, Audio Tapes
Digital DeliveryOnline via iMemories CloudDigital download (additional cost)
Physical DeliveryDVDs, Thumb DriveDVDs, CDs, Thumb Drive
Pricing StructurePer item pricing model, with additional cost for physical mediaBundle pricing model, different sizes of boxes
Customer SupportPhone, EmailPhone, Email
Turnaround TimeApproximately 3-4 weeksApproximately 6-8 weeks
Customer User ReviewsGenerally positive, praised for quality and serviceMixed, praised for quality but some concerns about turnaround time and customer service
Extra FeaturesApp for viewing and sharing, safe and secure storageBarcode system for tracking progress
CostCheck Current PricingCheck Current Pricing

Overview: What are iMemories and Legacybox?

iMemories is a service that combines image and footage digitization with 21st century streaming media. It scans images from analog materials like undeveloped film rolls, negatives, filmstrips, and even video recordings into high-quality files that can be kept in an online archive, posted on a blog or social media, and even streamed through its proprietary app like your favorite films or binge-worthy shows.

imemories vs legacybox reviews
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

On the other hand, Legacybox is a service that digitizes different forms of analog media. By “analog,” we’re talking about old-school VHS and Betamax cassettes, film negatives, Super 8 film footage, and even audio recordings on cassette or vinyl.

imemories vs legacybox reviews



iMemories lets you load up to 1,500 photo prints, 10,000 photographic negatives, and even 150 film reels (dependent on format) into a crush-proof box that you ship over to them. You can have your material shipped back as DVDs, stored in a secure flash drive, or accessed through the cloud to stream through the app.

imemories before and after


Legacybox offers a similar practice. You order a box from the service, then fill it up with the materials you want converted into digital files. A step-by-step guide comes with the box, and that includes shipping instructions. Pack, ship, and you get your files sent back in a secure thumb drive, a set of DVDs, or a secure download link that lets you drop everything into Google Drive.

legacybox imemories vs legacybox 2

Winner – iMemories! This phase of iMemories vs Legacybox is a close one, but iMemories gets the win thanks to the option of streaming one’s memories.



While most services offer three weeks as their fastest, iMemories has you covered in two. The service ships your converted files back in as early as two weeks and any streaming footage is digitally mastered to look as bright as the day it was filmed.



The main issue with Legacybox is that it takes 10 to 12 weeks before you get your digital files. But Legacybox’s team of imaging professionals ensures that all analog media sent are re-recorded and remastered for clarity and quality. That said, it may take a while, but you know your memories are in good hands.

legacybox imemories vs legacybox 3

Winner – iMemories! Need it back fast? iMemories has you covered with a speedy service that doesn’t skimp on quality.

Security and Privacy

Both iMemories and Legacybox have specific measures to ensure the privacy and security of the data.


iMemories uses proprietary software to track every item for digitization. Their cloud service provides online access to your digital content which is password-protected for added security.


Legacybox also prioritizes data security, with each item barcoded for individual tracking. They provide secure digital downloads, which let you access your digitized content securely.

File Quality


iMemories offers a resolution of up to 600 dpi for photos and 1080p for videos. Their team uses professional-grade equipment and software for digitization, ensuring a high-quality result. Their service also includes color correction, brightness, and contrast adjustments for better quality output.


Legacybox also uses advanced technology for digitization, providing clear, high-resolution digital files. While they don't disclose the exact resolution details, customer reviews often praise the quality of their digital outputs.



  • Submission Box
    • Varying capacity depending on media format;
    • Security barcodes for safe submission; and
    • Pre-printed shipping label
  • Output Formats
    • Link access to cloud with app-based streaming;
    • Secured thumb drive; and
    • Burning to standard DVD.
image © 2024. all rights reserved.


  • Submission Box
    • Varying capacity from two to 40 analog materials for digital conversion;
    • How-to guide;
    • Security barcodes for safe submission; and
    • Pre-printed shipping label
  • Output Formats
    • Link access to cloud with unlimited downloads and a 90-day secure backup;
    • Secured thumb drive; and
    • Burning to standard DVD.
legacybox imemories vs legacybox 4

Winner – iMemories! Again, this was close fight between iMemories vs LegacyBox, but we’re giving it to iMemories in terms of maximum capacity.


Information about the environmental impact of the services offered by iMemories and Legacybox is somewhat limited. They don't specifically mention any eco-friendly practices or detail how they dispose of physical materials after digitization. However, digitization itself contributes to reducing physical clutter and potentially the need for physical storage space, which can have an environmental benefit.

Additional Services


iMemories provides an additional service of video editing. With this feature, users can customize their digitized videos by adding music, titles, and transitions.


On the other hand, Legacybox doesn't seem to offer additional editing services but stands out with the variety of options for output formats. This includes physical outputs like DVDs and thumb drives, as well as digital download links.

iMemories vs LegacyBox Customer Support


iMemories provides customer support through phone and email. They also have an extensive FAQ section on their website to help customers with common queries.


Legacybox offers customer support via phone and email as well, and they also have a detailed FAQ page. Additionally, they offer tracking for your order, allowing you to know the status of your digitization process.

iMemories vs LegacyBox Value for Money


imemories pricing
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Base fee (taxes included) for iMemories’ SafeShip kit includes prices above. The streaming app is free to download, but you’ll need to pay $49.99 a year to subscribe to the iMemories Cloud storage/streaming capability.

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

iMemories has a 30-day return or refund policy.

Get your analog products digitized through iMemories via their official website only.


legacybox imemories vs legacybox pricing

Legacybox standard digitization packages depend on whether you're digitizing two items to a 40-item package. Regardless of output format, digitization charges are set at $19.99.

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

Also, if you aren’t happy with the service, you can return the output and file for a refund within 30 days upon receipt of the finished product.

We recommend that you get the service only through the official website to ensure quality service and output.

Winner – iMemories! Talk about state of the art – iMemories gets the vote for value for money.

iMemories vs LegacyBox User Reviews


iMemories currently has a 4.6-star rating on Trustpilot, with five-star ratings making up 78% of the 297 reviews on record. Those who rated the service consider it a great investment for saving family memories and milestone events.

image © 2024. all rights reserved.


Legacybox currently has a 3.9-stars rating on Trustpilot with five-star reviews making up 52% of the 616 currently on record. Most of those who reviewed the service appreciated the clear submission instructions, secure delivery, and satisfying output.

image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Winner – iMemories! Again, we’re giving the win to iMemories in this iMemories vs LegacyBox user reviews comparison.

Conclusion and Recommendation to our iMemories vs LegacyBox review

Who is iMemories best for?

We recommend this service to more digitally-savvy people who want to share their memories online through new-generation apps and social media.

Who is Legacybox best for?

Legacybox works best for those who want quality digitization services but are willing to wait.

iMemories vs Legacybox Alternatives

CompanyServices OfferedUnique FeaturesPrice Range
🏆 iMemoriesTapes, film, photos, slidesCloud storage, online sharing$$-$$$
LegacyboxVHS, film, photosEasy kits, bulk discounts$$-$$$
YesVideoVHS tapes, camcorder tapes, film reels, slidesOnline viewing and sharing$$
EverPresentVideo tapes, movie films, photos, slides, audioCustom editing, private consultations$$$
SouthtreeSimilar to LegacyboxFrequent promotions$$-$$$
ScanCafePhotos, slides, negatives, video tapesHigh-resolution, manual color correction$$-$$$
ScanMyPhotosPhotos, slides, film reelsFast service, bulk pricing$-$$
Digital MemoriesFilm, photos, slides, audioCustom storage solutions$$-$$$
ScanDigitalAll types of mediaCareful handling of media, comprehensive services$$-$$$
Memory FortressPhotos, videos, audio tapesQuick turnaround, straightforward pricing$-$$

iMemories vs LegacyBox Final Word

We appreciate it when a digital service delivers on time and in terms of value and quality. That said, iMemories gets our vote as the winner in our iMemories vs Legacybox comparison.

Please note that to get authentic, high-quality products, we recommend that you avail of iMemories only from their official website. You may also get great discounts for multiple purchases. Beware of purchasing from marketplace sites claiming to be resellers so to avoid issues with refunds and returns in the future!


Is the iMemories app free?

Yes, it’s also downloadable for both Android and iOS devices.

Can I have Hollywood films on tape converted via iMemories?

No, the service has a strict policy against the unwarranted reproduction of full-format films, television show episodes, and similar forms of copyrighted material.

If you've read all the way through this iMemories vs LegacyBox comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed all these products in detail, feel free to check them out;


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.