Home » Wellness » Simple Tilcare vs AirPhysio Comparison 2024: Which is Better?

Simple Tilcare vs AirPhysio Comparison 2024: Which is Better?

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between Tilcare vs AirPhysio, the better breathing device between the two is Airphysio.

Introduction to Tilcare vs AirPhysio Comparison

Which between Tilcare vs AirPhysio is the better breathing device for you?

Oscillating positive expiratory pressure (OPEP) devices are used in the management of numerous respiratory disorders like asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder (COPD), as well as helping those who have undergone a bout of bronchitis or pneumonia bounce back to better health.

As these are meant to be health management devices, they are built to be portable and ready for use anywhere. But, as we have said frequently, not all devices are made alike; some OPEPs work better than others, after all.

So which one could be the device for you? That’s what we intend to find out in today’s Tilcare vs AirPhysio comparison review. 

What are Tilcare and AirPhysio?

To give it its proper name, the Tilcare Mucus Exhaler Device is a portable OPEP device that, as its name suggests, helps dislodge mucus buildup from the lungs. It is also used to expand the lungs and improve their overall capacity with regular use. 

tilcare vs airphysio: photo of an airphysio breathing device

AirPhysio, on the other hand, is also a handy OPEP that was developed by a team of Australian physicians to improve the breathing patterns of athletes, those with longstanding respiratory conditions, and those recovering from respiratory illnesses such as bronchitis, pneumonia, and COVID-19. As with the Tilcare, it helps decrease mucus buildup and enables patients to easily expel phlegm to feel relief.

tilcare 1

Tilcare vs AirPhysio Quick Comparison Table

Note: Prices are subject to change over time. Please click the links to check for current pricing.

FeatureTilcare🏆 AirPhysio (Editor's Pick!)
Product TypeOPEPOPEP
CostCheck Current PricingCheck Current Pricing
ApplicationAdults and childrenSpecific models for adults and children
Battery RequirementNoneNone
ConfigurationMultiple settings depending on the size of ball bearing installedSingle-setting therapy
Customer SupportEmail direct or via online formPhone, email, standard post
Customer User Reviews3.9 out of 5 (Amazon)4.1 out of 5 (Amazon)
Recommended Use – ConditionsCOPD;Pneumonia;Asthma;Bronchitis;Cystic fibrosisAsthma;Atelectasis;Bronchiectasis;Cystic fibrosis;COPD;Obstructive sleep apnea;Emphysema;Chronic bronchitis

Usability

AirPhysio

Developed by Australian physicians, AirPhysio gets the job done with the simplest of configurations: a weighted ball bearing that oscillates as one breathes into the device. Depending on the use, the bearing within is appropriately sized for adults (sporting, reduced lung capacity, and standard therapeutic) and children. As such, it helps build lung capacity for better stamina in healthy individuals while helping clear the lungs of those with respiratory issues. 

airphysio vs acapella: woman using airphsyio
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Tilcare

On the official product page, Tilcare was being touted as a mucus extraction / lung capacity-building device. However, save for the fact that it was referred to as an OPEP device, no details as to its effective mechanism were given. In which case, we assume that it also relies on the same ball-bearing mechanism common to many OPEPs in the market. What it has going for it is an additional filter that can remove impurities from the air as one breathes in.

tilcare 4 1

How do Air Physio Tilcare breathing lung expander device fare in terms of usability?

Winner – AirPhysio! Close, but we’re giving the round to AirPhysio in this Tilcare vs AirPhysio usability battle.


Reliability

AirPhysio

Portable and lightweight construction is what has made AirPhysio a great favorite among users. This has enabled them to bring their OPEP anywhere for use whenever necessary – certainly an improvement on huge CPAP machines. Plus, batteries or electrical connections aren’t necessary. 

airphysio-reviews

Tilcare

We could say the same thing about Tilcare: it’s small enough to carry around in your pocket. In case you have trouble breathing or feel phlegm building up, just take it out and breathe.

tilcare 3

Winner – Draw! We’re calling the Tilcare vs AirPhysio reliability round a tie.


Features

AirPhysio

  • Single ball bearing configuration;
  • Portable and lightweight construction;
  • Doesn’t require the use of other medical devices;
  • Dedicated case for Air Physio device;
  • Non habit-forming as it doesn’t rely on chemical preparations;
  • Variants for standard therapeutic use, severe treatment, athletes, and children 
  • Developed and vetted by medical professionals;
  • Easy to clean.
airphysio2 1

Tilcare

  • Single ball bearing mechanism;
  • Portable and lightweight construction;
  • Non-pharmaceutical;
  • Detachable filter
  • Tilcare breathing lung expander carrying case
tilcare 2

Winner – AirPhysio! Where features are concerned between AirPhysio vs Tilcare breathing exercise device, we’d rather go with the properly vetted AirPhysio.


Value for Money

AirPhysio

AirPhysio’s hefty $59.99 (standard, sport, pediatric) and $73.99 (compromised lung function) price tags may give you sticker shock at first, but believe us when we say it’s worth it. Taxes are already computed in the price, but shipping is dependent on the order’s final destination.

airphysio pricing

A 30-day money-back guarantee applies, and we recommend getting it from the official website.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Tilcare

The Tilcare Mucus Exhaler is available for purchase through the official website, but the price listed was $39.99. Note that neither taxes nor shipping fees are included in the quoted price.

tilcare pricing

As with AirPhysio a 30-day money back guarantee applies.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Winner – AirPhysio! AirPhysio may be more expensive, but we like how it has different types for different respiratory needs.


User Reviews

AirPhysio

AirPhysio has an above average rating on Amazon with a healthy 4.1 stars out of 5. Users like the availability of different variants to suit the diverse needs of individual patients. 

airphysio amazon 1
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Tilcare

Tilcare presently holds a 4 out of 5 rating on Amazon. Users criticized its one-size-fits-all approach to respiratory care, pointing out that it was not always appropriate to the purpose for which it was purchased.

tilcare amazon
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Winner – AirPhysio! We are giving this round to AirPhysio.


Conclusion and Recommendations to our Tilcare vs AirPhysio Comparison

Who is the AirPhysio best for?

This device is recommended for standard and pediatric respiratory therapy, athletic training, as well as the mitigation of symptoms for severe respiratory issues.

Who is the Tilcare best for?

Tilcare is best for milder respiratory issues in adults.

Tilcare vs AirPhysio Alternatives

If you need one for personal use, there’s Kan-Breathe while Acapella works in clinical settings.

Tilcare vs AirPhysio Final Word

Given how AirPhysio was developed by doctors and it has already undergone numerous clinical trials across the globe, it comes away as the top pick in today’s Tilcare vs AirPhysio comparison review. Still, AirPhysio may get the doctors’ nod, but we suggest you see your own healthcare practitioner first before getting one for yourself.

Remember to protect yourself as a consumer by purchasing only authentic, high-quality products. Thereforewe recommend that you buy AirPhysio only from their official websiteNot only will you ensure you get legit products, but you can also save through discounted pricing for multiple buys. Beware of purchasing from marketplace sites claiming to be resellers so to avoid issues with refunds and returns in the future!


FAQ

Has AirPhysio been tested for use in the care / aftercare of COVID-19 patients?

Yes, ongoing clinical trials in India show that the device can be used to improve lung function among those recovering from moderate to severe COVID. At present, results are promising but research still has a long way to go.

Can I use the AirPhysio for physical training?

Yes. The Sport edition of the device was specifically developed for athletes, especially those in sports that require a great deal of lung capacity and efficient breathing.

What do doctors think of AirPhysio?

Doctors' opinions may vary, but generally, AirPhysio is considered a useful tool for people with chronic respiratory conditions like COPD, asthma, or bronchiectasis. It's often used as an adjunct to standard medical treatments, but you should consult your healthcare provider for personalized advice.

What is the alternative to AirPhysio?

Alternative devices to AirPhysio include Acapella, Flutter, and Tilcare, among others. These devices also use Oscillating Positive Expiratory Pressure (OPEP) or similar mechanisms to help clear mucus and improve lung function. It's essential to consult your healthcare provider to determine which device may be best suited for your needs.

What is the best lung cleaning device?

Determining the “best” lung-cleaning device is subjective and depends on individual needs, medical conditions, and the advice of healthcare professionals. Options include AirPhysio, Acapella, and Flutter devices. Always consult with a medical professional for personalized recommendations.

How does Tilcare work?

This generally involves exhaling through the device, which creates vibrations that loosen mucus, making it easier to cough up. It's best to consult the product's user manual or a healthcare provider for detailed information on how it works.


If you've read all the way through this Tilcare vs AirPhysio comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed several other products in detail, feel free to check them out;

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.