Home » Wellness » Simple FitTrack vs Withings Best Smart Scales Comparison 2024: Who Wins?

Simple FitTrack vs Withings Best Smart Scales Comparison 2024: Who Wins?

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between FitTrack vs Withings, the better smart scale between the two is FitTrack.

Introduction to FitTrack vs Withings Comparison

Which one is the superior smart scale between FitTrack vs Withings?

The concept of multitasking doesn’t just apply to ourselves in terms of work and life, but also to the devices that we use on a daily basis.

For example: our smartphones aren’t just used for communication anymore. These days, we also use them to work thanks to a number of applications, and to entertain ourselves thanks to a growing range of both games and streaming services.

And if phones can be turned into multipurpose devices, then why not our common bathroom scale? For this reason, we’re doing a comparison review of FitTrack vs Withings to see which of these products offers a better deal to customers.

What are FitTrack and Withings?

While FitTrack is best known for its health-tracking smartwatch, it also offers other ways by which you can keep tabs on your health. In this case, we’re talking about their FitTrack Dara, a smart scale that you can sync with a mobile device in order to monitor seventeen different aspects in order to get a comprehensive look at the state of your health.

Then there’s the Withings Body, a smart scale that helps you make informed decisions regarding weight management thanks to personalized insights that it generates every time you step on it.  

Now let's get a move on our comparison of Withings Scale vs FitTrack!


FitTrack vs Withings Quick Comparison Table

For your convenience, here's a quick summary of Withings vs FitTrack.

Note: Prices are subject to change over time for FitTrack Scale vs Withings. Please click the links to check for current pricing.

Feature🏆 FitTrack (Editor's Pick!)Withings
Product TypeSmart scale / body analysis device Smart scale / body analysis device 
CostCheck Current PricingCheck Current Pricing
ApplicationAnyone regardless of age, but moreso for those on a fitness / diet regimen Anyone regardless of age, but best for weight management
Battery Requirement / LifeFour AAA batteries 
1 year
Four AAA batteries 
6-8 months
Number of Metrics Covered173
Customer SupportSocial media, email, standard mail, customer hotline Email via form, online live chat, online community
Customer User Reviews4.2 out of 5 (Amazon) 4.4 out of 5 (Amazon)
Additional Services Offered Health and wellness coaching;Nutrition tracking;Recommended workoutsN/A

Usability

How does Withings vs FitTrack fare in terms of usability?

FitTrack 

The best thing about the FitTrack Dara is that it offers seventeen different metrics, including your body mass index (BMI), body fat percentage, muscle mass, and even hydration. 

In addition, it also helps you move forward in your fitness journey as it recommends workouts and even nutritional advice based on your metrics. 

FitTrack Dara Weight Limit

FitTrack Dara can accurately measure weights up to 396 pounds (180 kg). This makes it a versatile choice for individuals of various sizes. Overloading the scale could result in inaccurate measurements or, in extreme cases, damage to the device.

fittrack 02
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Withings

Much as we wanted to like Withings in terms of usability, it hardly goes beyond the aspect of weight management. To be fair, it does offer insights based on your current weight and also shows you a working record of your weight trends over time.

Withings Body Weight Limit

The Withings Body smart scale also has a maximum weight limit of 396 pounds (180 kg). Similar to FitTrack Dara, exceeding this limit could affect the accuracy and longevity of the product.

withings 1

Winner – FitTrack! Between FitTrack vs Withings, we found the FitTrack Dara more useful thanks to its numerous features.


App Experience

An often overlooked but crucial aspect of using a smart scale is the app experience. Both FitTrack and Withings offer companion apps to sync and analyze your health metrics. However, their approaches differ, offering unique user experiences.

FitTrack's Hume App

FitTrack offers its proprietary Hume mobile application, which is designed to be user-friendly and highly informative. Upon opening the app, you're greeted with a clean dashboard that displays your key metrics in an easily digestible format. Navigation is intuitive, and the app syncs seamlessly with your FitTrack Dara, updating your metrics in real-time. A standout feature is the personalized advice on workouts and nutrition, tailored to your latest health metrics. Moreover, the app is compatible with other popular fitness apps and wearable devices, allowing you to aggregate data for a fuller picture of your health.

Withings' Health Mate App

The Withings Health Mate application takes a minimalist approach. Its clean, uncluttered interface makes it easy for anyone to navigate through the app. One of its unique features is the daily weather forecast, which is an interesting add-on. The app excels in tracking weight trends over time, helping you see your progress or identify areas that need attention. While not as feature-rich as FitTrack's app, it offers a streamlined experience focused on weight management. Data synchronization happens automatically, making the process hassle-free.

Syncing Experience

Both apps excel in ease of data synchronization. FitTrack and Withings automatically update the respective apps as soon as you step off the scale. There's no need to manually update or refresh the app, which is a convenience in today's fast-paced world.

Why Is App Experience Important?

A seamless app experience not only makes it easier to track your metrics but also encourages consistent usage. User-friendly interfaces, quick data synchronization, and insightful features can greatly enhance your journey toward health and fitness.

Winner – FitTrack! Between FitTrack vs Withings, we found the FitTrack Dara more feature rich!


Reliability

FitTrack 

Reliability in this case is based on just how accurate each of these scales is. In FitTrack’s case, its Bioelectric Impedance Analysis (BIA) is one of the most accurate we’ve seen of any smart scale we have reviewed thus far. Indeed, the product’s Dexa Scan error margin (a metric specifically created to measure the accuracy of weighing scales for humans) is just +/-3% – a high accuracy rate for one’s weight and other relevant metrics.

chelsey evans 5

Withings

With the Withings Body, it is not exactly possible to get an apples-is-to-apples comparison as it uses a different metric technology. Despite this, many users point out the overall inaccuracy of the Withings, especially when it comes to one’s BMI. Indeed, it really puts people off when they get a good reading as healthy on a Dexa-compliant scale and discover that the Withings Body Cardio considers them obese!

withings 4

Winner – FitTrack! Comparing FitTrack vs Withings, FitTrack Dara wins in terms of reliability.


Features

Let's take a look at the features of these smart scales for monitoring BMI and other indicators.

FitTrack 

  • Seventeen specific metrics, including BMI, hydration, and percentage of body fat;
  • BIA scanning technology with Dexa +/-3% margin of error;
  • Proprietary Hume mobile application than can be used with some of the more popular fitness apps and wearable devices;
  • Can be used by up to twelve users 

FitTrack Dara Third-party App Integration

The FitTrack Dara shines in this category. It comes with its proprietary Hume mobile application, which is already comprehensive. However, if you're already invested in other fitness ecosystems, you'll be pleased to know that FitTrack Dara integrates smoothly with popular apps like Apple Health, Google Fit, and Fitbit. This makes it easier to aggregate all your health data in one place for a holistic view of your well-being.

fittrack vs withings: photo of fittrack app
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Withings

  • Instant weight insights recorded whenever you use the scale;
  • Proprietary Health Mate application for mobile with automatic synchronization feature;
  • Daily weather forecast;
  • Can only be used by up to eight users

Withings Body Third-party App Integration

Withings Body also offers third-party app integration through its Health Mate application. It's compatible with over 100+ health and fitness apps, including Apple Health, Google Fit, and MyFitnessPal. However, some users have reported that the integration process can be a bit more cumbersome compared to FitTrack Dara.

withings 6

Winner – FitTrack! This was FitTrack’s category to win in this FitTrack vs Withings features comparison.


Health Metrics Details

When deciding on a smart scale, the number of health metrics each device can measure is a key factor to consider. Let's dig deeper into this aspect to understand what sets FitTrack and Withings apart.

FitTrack's Metrics

FitTrack Dara measures an impressive 17 different metrics. This includes not just your weight, but also Body Mass Index (BMI), body fat percentage, muscle mass, hydration levels, and even your metabolic age. These comprehensive metrics provide a holistic view of your health, allowing you to focus on specific wellness goals. Whether you're looking to build muscle, lose fat, or simply maintain a healthy lifestyle, FitTrack offers a broad spectrum of data points to guide your journey.

fittrack vs renpho: woman holding a fittrack dara smart scale

Withings' Metrics

On the other hand, Withings focuses on fewer metrics but aims for high-quality data in those categories. In addition to weight, it provides your BMI and insights into weight trends over time. While not as comprehensive as FitTrack, Withings excels in delivering in-depth data for weight management. This can be particularly useful for individuals who are looking to lose or maintain weight and want to keep things simple.

withings 2

Why Are These Metrics Important?

Understanding your body composition can offer invaluable insights into your overall health and fitness. Metrics like body fat percentage can provide a more accurate picture of your fitness than weight alone, helping you tailor your exercise and diet plans more effectively. Furthermore, tracking these metrics over time allows you to measure the effectiveness of your health routines and make data-driven adjustments.

Winner – FitTrack! FitTrack tracks more metircs!


Value for Money

FitTrack 

Excluding retail taxes and shipping / handling fees, each FitTrack Dara costs about $89.99. While it’s a bit cheaper on Amazon, it would be best to buy the item from the official website.

fittrack-dara-reviews
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

FitTrack Dara Warranty and Customer Service

Together with a two-year service warranty, FitTrack offers users a 30-day money-back guarantee, a feature that stands out in the market. But what makes it even more compelling is the quality of their customer service. Users often highlight the company's fast response times and willingness to address issues or concerns, whether it's about calibration, app syncing, or hardware glitches.

Make sure to purchase this smart scale only through their official website.

Other Stores

The smart scale available on Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay but best to avoid reseller sites like that for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Withings

The Withings Body is the brand’s most basic model and it will set you back by 99.95, excluding all the usual taxes, as well as shipping and handling fees. 

withings pricing

Withings Body Warranty and Customer Service

Interestingly, Withings’ refund policy is much shorter at just fourteen days, which can be restrictive for some users. While their customer service is competent and accessible through multiple channels, some users have complained about slower response times and difficulties in replacing defective units.

Make sure to purchase this smart scale only through their official website.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Winner – FitTrack! The cost is about $30 higher, but FitTrack definitely offers a better deal.


Durability: Built to Last?

Durability can often be a deciding factor when choosing between smart scales. After all, these are devices meant to be stepped on regularly. Therefore, the quality of materials used and the build should be able to withstand everyday wear and tear.

FitTrack Dara Durability

The FitTrack Dara is constructed with high-quality tempered glass and a sturdy ABS plastic base. The glass is designed to be non-slip, a useful safety feature. Additionally, the scale has been tested to accommodate weight up to 400 pounds, which is relatively high compared to many other smart scales. The inclusion of a two-year service warranty offers an extra layer of confidence in the product's durability.

Withings Body Durability

The Withings Body is also built with tempered glass but lacks the non-slip feature found in the FitTrack Dara. This can be a significant downside, especially for users who are concerned about slipping. It is designed to accommodate weight up to 396 pounds, which is comparable to the FitTrack Dara. However, the shorter 14-day refund policy may raise some concerns about the manufacturer's confidence in long-term durability.

Material Matters

Both scales use tempered glass, which is known for its strength and durability. However, FitTrack gains a slight edge with its non-slip surface, which not only enhances user safety but also potentially extends the product's lifespan by reducing the risk of accidents.

Why Durability Matters

Investing in a durable smart scale means you're less likely to spend on replacements or repairs. Sturdiness also ensures that the scale can handle daily usage, providing consistent and accurate readings over time.

Winner – FitTrack! Withings lacks the nopn-slip feature and has a shorter refund policy


User Reviews

FitTrack 

While FitTrack is the lower scorer at a respectable 4.2 out of 5 rating on Amazon, it remains a favorite among buyers. While accuracy and usability are its strongest points, users also like its innate safety features (it’s non-slip, after all) and its elegant look. 

fittrack amazon
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Withings 

While Withings has a 4.4 rating on Amazon, its safety has been called into question by users. The scale’s glass surface is slippery when wet and that’s a major red flag for users who are none too steady on their feet and definitely for the elderly.

withings amazon
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Winner – FitTrack! Between Fittrack vs Withings, safety first say the customers, and FitTrack gets their vote.


Conclusion and Recommendations to our FitTrack vs Withings Comparison

To wrap up our FitTrack vs Withings, from accuracy to safety, it’s obvious that FitTrack has everything covered.

Who is FitTrack best for?

Anyone who wants to keep tabs on different aspects of their health aside from their weight.

Who is Withings best for?

It’s one of the best smart scales to use for weight management.

FitTrack vs Withings Alternatives

While there are a lot of possible options, the offerings from;

  • Fitbit: Offers a wide array of health metrics and is generally more budget-friendly.
  • Garmin Index Smart Scale: Known for integrating well with Garmin's fitness trackers and smartwatches.
  • Eufy Smart Scale: A budget-friendly option that offers essential metrics.
  • QardioBase 2: Focuses on design and ease-of-use and offers unique features like a pregnancy mode.

FitTrack vs Withings Final Word

This was FitTrack’s review to win, and we urge you to try it!

A word of advice: Remember to protect yourself as a consumer by purchasing only authentic, high-quality products. Thereforewe recommend that you buy FitTrack only from their official websiteNot only will you ensure you get legit products, but you can also save through discounted pricing for multiple buys. Beware of purchasing from marketplace sites claiming to be resellers so to avoid issues with refunds and returns in the future!


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I use my FitTrack scale with my smart watch?

Yes, and you can also sync it with some of the more popular health apps, including Apple Health and Google Fit.

Does Withings come in a single color way?

No, the product comes in two: black and white.

Is FitTrack actually accurate?

FitTrack smart scales are generally considered to be accurate for consumer-grade devices. They use bioelectrical impedance to estimate various health metrics such as body fat percentage, muscle mass, and hydration levels. While the measurements are usually precise enough for tracking trends over time, it's essential to note that no consumer-grade scale can replace medical evaluation for health metrics.

Is Withings an accurate scale?

Withings scales are known for their accuracy and reliability. They use similar bioelectrical impedance technology as FitTrack to measure various health indicators. The scale can also automatically calibrate itself for higher accuracy. However, as with all consumer-grade health devices, Withings scales should not be considered as medically accurate as tests you would receive in a clinical setting.

Is Withings Smart scale worth it?

The value of a Withings Smart scale often lies in its premium design, user-friendly app interface, and integration with other Withings health products. If you're looking for a sleek, well-designed smart scale that offers reliable readings and can sync with a broader health ecosystem, then a Withings Smart scale may well be worth the investment.

What are Withings scale competitors?

Withings scales face competition from various brands in the smart scale market. Some notable competitors include FitBit, Garmin Index Smart Scale, Eufy Smart Scale, QardioBase 2.Each of these competitors has its own set of features and benefits, so the right choice depends on your specific needs and preferences.

Is FitTrack Dara water-resistant?

The FitTrack Dara is designed to handle the occasional splash but is not rated as fully water-resistant. It's recommended to keep the scale dry for optimal performance.

Is Withings Body water-resistant?

Withings Body is not advertised as being water-resistant, although its build quality suggests it could handle minor splashes. For safety and durability, it is best kept dry.

How often do I need to calibrate FitTrack for accurate measurements?

FitTrack recommends calibrating the scale once a month or whenever it's moved to a different location. The app provides step-by-step instructions for calibration.

How often does Withings require calibration?

Withings scales are generally self-calibrating and do not require manual intervention as often as some other brands. However, it's advisable to calibrate it if you notice inconsistencies in measurements.

How durable is FitTrack Dara?

FitTrack Dara is made from a combination of high-quality glass and plastic, designed for long-term use. However, like all electronic devices, proper care and maintenance are advised to maintain its durability.

How durable is Withings Body?

Withings Body is built from robust materials, including tempered glass, which contributes to its durability. As with FitTrack, proper care is essential for longevity.


If you've read all the way through this FitTrack vs Withings comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed several other products in detail, feel free to check them out;

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.