Home » Home & Garden » Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress: Best Choice 2024! 🛏️

Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress: Best Choice 2024! 🛏️

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

Welcome to our comparison of Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress! We all want the best for our little bundles of joy, and the best extends to the mattresses we place in their cribs to ensure that they get to sleep well through the night. But as not all mattresses are made equal, today’s Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress comparison review will show which of these is the better buy for you baby.

 Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress, the better infant sleep product for most people is Naturepedic.


The classic Naturepedic Crib Mattress is uniquely designed to support babies’ heads, necks, and backs as they sleep. Each one is filled with natural cotton to prevent irritating sensitive infant skin as well as allergies and other health issues. All company products were designed following pediatric recommendations by medical specialists, as well as the guidelines for child safety imposed by the US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).

naturepedic vs newton mattress
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

The Newton Mattress, on the other hand, is part of the Newton Baby line of infant sleep products. Much like the Naturepedic, it is designed to provide ample support for a baby’s fragile head, neck, and back. The materials are also soft and comfortable enough so as not to irritate infant skin. Newton Mattresses are certified natural under Greenguard standards.

newton mattress 3

Comparison of Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress

Note: Prices are subject to change over time. Please click the links to check for current pricing.

Feature🏆 Naturepedic (My Pick!)Newton
MaterialOrganic cotton and wool100% breathable polymer
Firmness optionsMultiple options availableSingle firmness option
WaterproofSome models are waterproofYes, waterproof
SupportInnerspring or organic latexPolymer support core
CertificationsGOTS, GOLS, Greenguard Gold certifiedGreenguard Gold certified
CoverOrganic cottonBreathable, washable cover
Price RangeHigh to premiumMid to high
Trial PeriodVaries by retailer100-night sleep trial
WarrantyVaries by modelLimited lifetime warranty
CostCheck Current PricingCheck Current Pricing



The Naturepedic Crib Mattress can be used for just about any standard crib, rectangular or oval. In its larger forms, the mattress is also appropriate for toddler or preschooler beds. Plus it has a number of built-in / sewn-in features that make it very easy to set up and maintain, including lightweight construction for easy lifting and transportation. Plus, it has a waterproof exterior that easily wipes clean.

naturepedic crib mattress 8
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Newton Mattress

Unfortunately, we weren’t very happy with the Newton Mattress. As a crib mattress, it errs on the side of firmness. While that quality helps reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), it doesn’t provide enough comfort to help a baby – especially one who’s teething or ill – sleep well or restfully.

newton mattress 4

Winner – Naturepedic. In this Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress comparison, what’s the point of having a mattress on which your baby is unable to sleep?



We love how each mattress is well-stitched so it doesn’t fall apart at first wash. The fact that it was designed by pediatricians also means that it was built for durability, seeing how a child gains substantial weight in the first year of life. Indeed, their crib mattresses are so durable that your next baby can sleep on their older sibling’s Naturepedic with the same level of comfort.

naturepedic crib mattress 6

Newton Mattress

Disappointed would be an understatement here. The Newton Mattress cover feels flimsy and cheaply made, and you can see the wear and tear on the mattress itself after just a few months of use. The stitching is poorly done, leading to unraveling and fraying in multiple areas. 

newton mattress 4 1

Winner – Naturepedic! Naturepedic triumphs in this Naturepedic vs Newton mattress comparison, we appreciate a crib mattress that doesn’t skimp on comfort as well as durability.



  • Waterproof exterior that can be easily wiped clean;
  • Lightweight construction featuring a 150-coil design;
  • Wavesupport core for easy lifting and transportation;
  • Organic cotton batting fill; and
  • PLA fiber (derived from sugarcane) for durability.
naturepedic crib mattress 5
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Newton Mattress 

  • Machine-washable dual-layer quilted cover;
  • Natural fire-retardant viscose cover;
  • Wovenaire core made with 10% food-grade polymer; and 
  • Greenguard certification for sustainable manufacturing
newton mattress 2

Winner – Naturepedic! In this Naturepedic vs Newton mattress showdown, we like the construction as it essentially mimics an adult mattress, but offers plenty of room for a kid to grow on.

Value for Money


Prices for the classic Naturepedic Crib Mattress run between $269 and $329, depending on whether you’re getting a single-step or two-step option. (We suggest the latter as it adjusts as your baby grows.) Breathable and the Breathable Ultra options, on the other hand, cost a bit more. But all are worth the price thanks to sturdy construction, adjusting comfortably to the curves of your child’s body, and waterproofing.

naturepedic crib mattress pricing

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

Naturepedic offers a 100-night trial period for families who want to see if the mattress works for their little ones before committing to an actual purchase. However, for those who aren’t happy with the mattress, the company also offers a 30-day money back guarantee.

You may choose to buy a Naturepedic from the official website.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Newton Mattress

Newton’s original crib mattress is on the pricey side at $299 each – and it isn’t even waterproof. If you want the waterproof crib mattress, you’ll need to shell out $349 – and that’s still twenty dollars more than Naturepedic’s already waterproof two-step original.

newton pricing

Free trial/refund policy/money-back guarantee

The company offers a 100-night guarantee. If you aren’t happy with the product, you can send it back for a refund or store credit within the stipulated period.

You may choose to buy a Newton from the official website.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.

Winner – Naturepedic! Naturepedic takes the game in this Naturepedic vs Newton mattress comparison when it comes to value for money.

User Reviews


Naturepedic currently has a 4.4-stars rating on Amazon’s global scale with five-star reviews making up 76% of the 157 currently on record. Those who submitted positive reviews remarked that their children slept well and they were able to use the mattresses with successive infants.

naturepedic trustpilot
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Newton Mattress

While Newton Mattress got good reviews on its Amazon scale, the comments regarding the overall quality are telling. Many parents complained about a foul chemical reek coming from the mattress after only a week of use, and the food-grade polymer turned out to be cheap plastic.

newton mattress amazon 1
image © 2024. all rights reserved.

Winner – Naturepedic! Naturepedic wins among customers.

Conclusion and Recommendation to our Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress Comparison

Who is Naturepedic best for?

An excellent choice for healthy infants and toddlers. 

Who is Newton Mattress best for?

The firmness would be good for children with spinal issues.

Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress Alternatives

Need a clean, green, and comfy crib mattress? You may want to look at OMI Organic.

Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress Final Word

Naturepedic wins our Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress comparison – and for very good reason.

Please note that to get authentic, high-quality products, we recommend that you avail of Naturepedic only from their official website. You may also get great discounts for multiple purchases. Beware of purchasing from marketplace sites claiming to be resellers so to avoid issues with refunds and returns in the future!


What materials are used to fill Naturepedic Mattresses?

Organic cotton batting and an organic waterproofing material derived from sugarcane are used for the classic and breathable options.

How many springs are used in each mattress?

Depending on the mattress type, a Naturepedic Crib Mattress could have either 150 or 252 coils.

Are Naturepedic Crib Mattresses durable?

Yes, and you can be sure that you can use the mattresses for years to come.

If you've read all the way through this Naturepedic vs Newton Mattress comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed all these products in detail, feel free to check them out;


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.