Home ยป Pet Supplies ยป Barkbox vs Bullymake: Ultimate 2024 Pet Subscription Box Battle of 2024! ๐Ÿพ ๐Ÿ’ฅ

Barkbox vs Bullymake: Ultimate 2024 Pet Subscription Box Battle of 2024! ๐Ÿพ ๐Ÿ’ฅ

versus vs screen background in torn paper style

โณ Do you want to skip the read and get right to my pick? Between Barkbox vs Bullymake, the better subscription-based service for dogs between the two can go either way – depending on your specific needs and preferences – but personally, I'm rooting for Barkbox.

Introduction to my Comprehensive Comparison of Barkbox vs Bullymake

You're reading our in-depth comparison of Barkbox vs Bullymake!

When it comes to pampering our canine companions with new toys and treats, the decision between subscribing to BarkBox vs Bullymake is a common dilemma faced by dog owners. Both subscription services offer a monthly box filled with dog-friendly products, but they cater to different needs and preferences. BarkBox, renowned for its fun themes and variety, typically suits dogs of all sizes, particularly those with a medium chew strength.

On the other hand, Bullymake is specifically designed for power chewers, providing more durable toys and a range of customisation options for owners dealing with dogs that have specific dietary restrictions or allergies.

Comparing these two services goes beyond just price and toy count; it's essential to look at the overall value offered, including the quality and durability of the products, the ability to manage diet and allergy concerns, the flexibility of subscription options, and the level of customer service provided. Whether your dog is a gentle player or an aggressive chewer, understanding the nuances of what each box brings to your doorstep will guide you to the best choice for keeping your pooch happy and engaged. Global shipping options and accessibility also play a part in deciding, as does feedback from other dog owners, which is often available through user reviews.

Key Takeaways

  • Both BarkBox Super Chewer vs Bullymake are designed to surprise your dog with new toys and treats every month.
  • BarkBox is generally suitable for medium chewers, while Bullymake caters to dogs that are power chewers.
  • Choosing between the two involves considering product quality, customisation for dietary needs, and customer service.

Quick Comparison Table

Below is the comparison between Bullymake vs BarkBox Super Chewer, two popular dog subscription box services which cater to dogs of different sizes and chewing habits:

Feature๐Ÿ† BarkBoxBullymake
PriceRoughly ยฃ29/monthStarts at about ยฃ29/month
ShippingFree to all US StatesFree to all US States
ContentsUsually includes 2 innovative toys, 2 all-natural bags of treats, and a chewTypically provides 2-3 toys and 3 bags of treats
Allergy OptionsAccommodates for beef, chicken, and grain allergiesCater to beef, chicken, and grain allergies
Toy DurabilityOffers a variety of toys suitable for different types of playKnown for more durable toys, designed for heavy chewers
CustomisationCan select toy preferencesOffers material preferences for toys
Subscription PlansFour options available, tailored to different dog sizes and needsUsually a single subscription plan with less variety
GuaranteesSatisfaction guarantee availableOffers a 14-day guarantee

BarkBox provides a broad variety of toys and is a great choice for dogs that enjoy softer, more plush toys. In contrast, Bullymake is aimed towards canines who are notorious for their ability to destroy standard toys, as their selection is crafted for endurance.

I find that BarkBox's offerings include creative and fun themes which change monthly, while Bullymake maintains a consistent approach to durability without a thematic variety. Subscribers of this best dog subscription services point out the quality and novelty of the products included, which are often a surprise and eagerly awaited by both pups and their owners.


Comparative Analysis of BarkBox and Bullymake

two dog subscription boxes side by side, one labeled "barkbox" and the other "bullymake." each box filled with various dog toys and treats

In this section, I'll explore the standout features of both BarkBox vs Bullymake. I'll discuss their brand presence, which dogs they're best suited for, and the variety of products they offer within their subscription boxes.

Brand Overview

BarkBox has become a well-known brand in the dog subscription box market, positioning itself as a provider of a delightful mix of toys, treats, and chews. Their BarkBox Super Chewer box is famed for offering durable toys more suited for dogs that put their playthings to rigorous tests. On the other hand, Bullymake, notching a similar reputation, prides itself on delivering a Bullymake Box that caters specifically to power-chewers, with every item designed to withstand the toughest of bites.

Target Canine Audience

BarkBox appeals to a wide range of pooches but is particularly tailored for smaller breeds or those that don't chew aggressively. Its Super Chewer option expands its audience to include dogs that are more spirited in their play and in need of sturdier toys. In contrast, every Bullymake Box is curated for strong-jawed dogs, therefore my options for a monthly theme-based box are more focused towards those breeds that necessitate tougher toys and stronger resistance.

Product Range

Within their subscription box, BarkBox typically provides two toys, two bags of treats and a chew. These items are often thematically linked and offer a joyful experience for both dog and owner upon unboxing each month. Comparatively, Bullymake's subscription options display a similar quantity but with an emphasis on the longevity of their toys, featuring 2-3 robust toys and 3 bags of treats that my power-chewer canine friends might find more satisfying.


Box Contents and Customisation

In my analysis of BarkBox vs Bullymake, I focus on how each service caters to the distinct preferences and needs of dogs through their customisation options and the quality of their box contents.

Customisation Possibilities

Both services offer notable customisation features. With BarkBox, I'm able to select a box that exclusively contains toys, which is perfect for pets with specific dietary needs or when I've already got a stockpile of treats. On the other hand, Bullymake allows me to choose the preference for toy material, ensuring the toys are suitable for my dog's level of chew strength.

Contents Quality

The quality of contents is paramount for both companies. BarkBox is known for their innovative and playful toys, which are not only durable but also cater to a dog's curiosity. Bullymake, tailored more towards aggressive chewers, features toys that are tough and long-lasting, perfect for dogs that tend to destroy their playthings quickly.

Dietary Considerations

For dogs with specific dietary requirements, both boxes offer options that can accommodate such needs. BarkBox can cater to beef, chicken, and grain allergies, ensuring the treats included are safe and enjoyable for my pet. Bullymake also provides a tailor-fitting experience by offering to adjust contents for common allergies, ensuring that the treats are not only safe but also contribute to a healthy diet with their all-natural ingredients.


Theme and Design

In evaluating BarkBox vs Bullymake, I've discovered that both services pride themselves on the creativity and thoughtfulness that goes into their monthly themes and the design quality of their products.

Monthly Theme

Each month, BarkBox curates a collection centred around a unique theme, from whimsical concepts like ‘Chewrassic Bark' to festive ‘Sniffin' Around the Christmas Tree'. These themed boxes are designed to excite both the dog and their owner, with playful and often humorous elements reflecting the theme in the toys and treats included.

Conversely, Bullymake positions itself as the tougher counterpart to BarkBox, catering especially to power chewers. Despite this, they do offer monthly themed boxes, ensuring that even the most durable toy comes with a twist of creativity, be it a seasonal celebration or an adventurous setting, delivering joy and variety to subscribers.

Design Quality

When it comes to design quality, BarkBox appears to focus heavily on the aesthetic aspect, ensuring that the toys not only fit the monthly theme but also charm owners with their vibrant colours and engaging shapes.

On the other hand, Bullymake emphasises durability in their designs, understanding that the main appeal for their customers lies in sturdy toys that endure. According to customer feedback, their products are made to withstand the enthusiastic play of large dogs and aggressive chewers, incorporating the monthly theme into the toy's resilient build.


Product Quality and Durability

two dog toys, one from barkbox and one from bullymake, are being tugged and chewed on by two energetic dogs, showing their durability and quality

In comparing BarkBox vs Bullymake, I've observed that each brand prioritises quality and uses durable materials to craft their chew toys, delving into the specificity of the construction of their products for a clearer insight.

Materials and Construction

Bullymake's toys are predominantly constructed using highly robust materials such as nylon and rubber, which are known for their resilience. These materials are especially chosen to withstand the aggressive chewing of larger breeds and power chewers. The toys are not just tough; they're also designed with your pet's safety in mind, ensuring they are a consistent component of durable toys within the pet industry.

Toy Durability

When examining the durability of the toys, BarkBox also provides a range of durable toys, usually themed around a monthly concept. Their toys are often a mix of plush and rubbery materials. While the plush toys may not stand up to heavy chewing as well as Bullymake's offerings, their rubbery toys are designed to be more durable. However, it's clear that Bullymake focuses more on sourcing tougher toys that cater specifically to the needs of dogs who need something more robust to sink their teeth into.


Allergy and Diet Management

barkbox vs bullymake

When it comes to selecting between BarkBox vs Bullymake as the right subscription box for my dog, managing their dietary needs and allergies is paramount. I prefer a service that can be customised to avoid any adverse reactions, while still providing a variety of treats and toys to keep them engaged.

Special Dietary Needs and Allergies

Grain Allergies: Many dogs, like mine, may have grain allergies which can lead to itchy skin and other discomforts. I found that Bullymake caters to this need by offering grain-free options, ensuring that the treats included in the box are safe for my dog to consume.

Protein Allergies: Protein sources such as beef and chicken are common allergens for pets. I appreciate that BarkBox offers customisation for beef, chicken, and grain allergies, allowing me to choose treats that won't trigger my dog's allergies.

Special Dietary Needs: For dogs with specific dietary requirements, finding suitable treats can be a challenge. The flexibility to select a box with only toys, as offered by BarkBox, ensures that my dog can still enjoy the excitement of new toys without risking their health.

By evaluating BarkBox vs Bullymake‘s approach to managing allergies and special dietary needs, I can make an informed choice that aligns with my dog's health and happiness.


Pricing and Value

two dog subscription boxes side by side, one labeled "barkbox" and the other "bullymake," with various dog toys and treats spilling out of them

When looking at BarkBox vs Bullymake, I consider various aspects of their offerings to determine which subscription provides the best bang for your buck. These include price points, refund policies, available discounts, and overall value for money.

Price Comparison

For BarkBox, the monthly cost generally sits at a slightly lower price point than Bullymake, with the option to obtain further reductions through longer-term commitments. On the other hand, Bullymake is priced at approximately $39/month, and the commitment to durability may justify the higher expense for owners of tougher chewers.

Refund Policy/Money-Back Guarantee

Both BarkBox vs Bullymake offer money-back guarantees, which showcase their confidence in product satisfaction. BarkBox notably includes a satisfaction guarantee that allows for a refund if my dog doesn't like their box, while Bullymake provides a 14-day guarantee, assuring replacements for any toys that don't hold up.

Discounts and Offers

Periodically, both BarkBox vs Bullymake extend special offers and discounts to new subscribers. Iโ€™ve noticed that BarkBox often includes additional items for first-time orders, and Bullymake occasionally offers a discount on the first box with a multi-month subscription plan.

Value for Money

My analysis shows that BarkBox offers a greater variety of toys which may add to the perceived value, particularly for smaller dogs. Conversely, Bullymake is recognised for its tailored approach toward heavy chewers and often includes toys that can withstand more rigorous play, which may provide better value for owners of these dogs. Both services include free shipping to all U.S. States, increasing the overall value of each box.

If you're interested in buying BarkBox, it's always better if you purchase it online via their official website.

Other Stores

Best to avoid reseller sites like that of Amazon, Facebook Marketplace and eBay for possible fake products and refund policy issues.


Subscription Options

a playful dog eagerly compares barkbox and bullymake subscription options, surrounded by colorful toys and treats

When choosing between BarkBox vs Bullymake, I find the range of subscription options paramount for accommodating different customer preferences and needs.

Subscription Terms

BarkBox offers flexible terms for their subscription service, including monthly subscriptions, a 6-month subscription, and a 12-month subscription. For those who prefer not to commit, the month-to-month option can be more appealing. Meanwhile, the longer-term subscriptions tend to be more cost-efficient. Bullymake also provides similar subscription services, giving me the option to select the term that best fits my requirements. Details found in the comparison between BarkBox and Bullymake reflect these choices clearly.

Subscription Types

Both services have distinct subscription types tailored to different dog sizes and chewing habits. BarkBox has a specialised subscription for heavy chewers called Super Chewer, which is slightly cheaper for the 6-month and annual plans compared to Bullymake. I appreciate that Bullymake targets dogs that are tough on toys, offering durability in their monthly subscription boxes. Each company has considered canine allergies too and can cater to specific dietary requirements.


Shipping and Accessibility

In my assessment of the shipping and accessibility of BarkBox vs Bullymake, I will focus on their delivery options and how widely they are available to consumers in different regions.

Shipping Options

Bulymake offers free shipping within the United States, ensuring that customers in all states, including Hawaii and Alaska, don't incur additional fees. Each delivery typically contains 2-3 toys and 3 bags of treats, and they pride themselves on prompt service with shipments going out the next day.

On the other hand, BarkBox provides a similar shipping policy across America, extending the free delivery to the entire U.S without any shipping costs. Packages from both services are typically sent quickly, meaning I can expect reliable and swift delivery of my monthly subscription box.

Geographical Availability

Both subscription services are primarily focused on the U.S. market, branding their products as made in the USA. However, they differ slightly when it comes to Canada. Bullymake maintains its appeal to North American customers by including Canada in their shipping destinations, albeit with an extra fee. For BarkBox, I found that it similarly reaches out to Canadian customers but didn't find specifics on additional charges or changes in service for them. Each company aims to cover a broad market by including all American regions in their delivery scope.

BarkBox vs Bullymake differ not just in the products they provide but also in how they reach their customers. Through my analysis, what became evident is that both take their accessibility for customers across the U.S. and Canada seriously, with minor differences in approach.


Customer Satisfaction and Service

a happy dog plays with a barkbox toy while another dog eagerly awaits a bullymake delivery, both wagging their tails in excitement

In my comparison of BarkBox vs Bullymake, I've found that both companies offer customer satisfaction guarantees and have robust customer support systems in place. Their dedication to providing a positive experience is evident through their service offerings.

Satisfaction Guarates

BarkBox provides a happiness guarantee where if a dog isn't happy with their product, I can simply reach out to their customer service team. They are known for their willingness to replace items, no questions asked. On the other hand, Bullymake also offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, with a promise to make it right should there be any issues. They offer a 14-day guarantee where if a toy doesn't hold up, they will replace it for free.

Customer Support

Customer support is vital, and both companies have comprehensive support systems. BarkBox boasts a friendly support team that is quick to address any concerns. Their response times are impressive, making sure that I am not left waiting for an answer. Bullymakeโ€™s customer service includes options for instant feedback on their website, should I need assistance in real-time. They also offer a range of contact methods to suit my preferences, whether it's through email, phone, or even text messages.


Users' Reviews

dogs eagerly inspecting barkbox and bullymake packages, wagging tails and sniffing toys and treats

In assessing the reviews for both BarkBox vs Bullymake, I've gathered user opinions from trusted platforms like TrustPilot and Reddit to ensure authenticity. Let me share that the tone of the reviews ranged quite broadly, from delight with the products to concerns about durability and suitability for different dog breeds.

TrustPilot Reviews:

  • BarkBox:

    • Positive: Users often praised the variety and creativity of toys and treats.
    • Concerns: Occasionally, there were comments about toys not being resilient enough for power chewers.
  • Bullymake:

    • Positive: Reviews commonly highlighted the box's suitability for dogs that are heavy chewers.
    • Concerns: Some users noted issues with customer service responsiveness and flexibility.

Reddit Reviews:

On Reddit, the feedback had a straightforward, community-driven angle.

  • BarkBox:

    • Experiences: Subscribers enjoy the themed boxes and sometimes share unboxing experiences.
    • Negatives: Some users reflected on toys being quickly destroyed by their dogs.
  • Bullymake:

    • Recommendations: Itโ€™s frequently recommended for its robust toys.
    • Criticisms: There have been occasional mentions of the treats not always being a hit with all pets.

I must note that individual reviews vary, but these summaries should give you a snapshot of the current sentiment. Every dog is unique, so what might be a hit for one might not impress another. It's a good idea to consider your dog's habits and preferences when choosing between these subscription boxes.


Conclusion & Personal Recommendation

In this final section, I detail who BarkBox vs Bullymake are most suitable for, explore alternatives, and give my definitive recommendation.

Who is BarkBox best for?

BarkBox caters well to smaller dogs that may not chew as aggressively. Their variety of toys is appealing for petite canines, and thereโ€™s an aspect of customisation which allows the box to cater to certain allergies.

Who is Bullymake best for?

On the other hand, Bullymake is my recommendation for larger dogs who are heavy chewers. Their toys are designed to withstand more rigorous play, and like BarkBox, they can accommodate preferences for dogs with beef, chicken, and grain allergies.

Alternatives

For those looking for variety beyond these two choices, services like Kong Club or regular trips to the pet store might suit your needs in terms of finding specific items for your petโ€™s breed and chewing habits.

Final Word

As a responsible pet owner, choosing between BarkBox vs Bullymake hinges on knowing your dogโ€™s size, chewing style, and dietary needs. Both offer quality products and have their specific strengths: BarkBox for variety and Bullymake for durability. Take the time to assess which matches your dogโ€™s characteristics and preferences to ensure your furry friend is satisfied. However, personally, my comparison winner here is BarkBox!


Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, I'll address some common queries regarding the BarkBox vs Bullymake subscription services. Each question is aimed at helping you distinguish between these two offerings to determine which may best suit your dog's needs.

What are the key differences between BarkBox and Bullymake subscription services?

BarkBox typically offers a wider range of products, including an assortment of toys and treats that cater to smaller dogs or those that are less aggressive with their toys. On the other hand, Bullymake focuses on providing durable toys more suited to heavy chewers and offers customisation options for dogs with specific dietary needs.

How do the costs compare between BarkBox and Bullymake?

When it comes to cost, BarkBox is generally a bit more affordable, particularly if your dog is not particularly hard on toys. Bullymake tends to be slightly more expensive, but they often include more robust toys that may stand up better to dogs that chew aggressively.

Which subscription is better suited for heavy chewers, BarkBox or Bullymake?

For heavy chewers, Bullymake is often the preferred choice, as the toys provided are specifically designed to be more durable against determined chewers. BarkBox's Super Chewer subscription is an alternative, designed to offer tougher toys as well.

Are there any notable differences in toy quality between BarkBox and Bullymake offerings?

The toy quality between the two services can vary significantly. BarkBox is known for its creativity and variety in toys, whereas Bullymake gears its toy selection towards durability and long-lasting design specifically for dogs that chew hard.

How do customer reviews on Reddit reflect the value of BarkBox versus Bullymake?

Customer reviews on Reddit suggest that the value perceived from either BarkBox or Bullymake can depend on the individual dog's behaviour. Those with dogs that are aggressive chewers tend to find better value in Bullymake's tough toys, while the variety in BarkBox seems to please owners of less destructive pets.

In terms of variety and interest, how do BarkBox and Bullymake boxes stack up against each other?

BarkBox often provides a broader assortment of toys and treats, which can keep things interesting for your pet. Bullymake, while possibly less varied, focuses on the sturdy construction of their toys, which may be more practical and longer-lasting for dogs that have a strong need to gnaw.


That's all for now:

If you've read all the way through this Barkbox vs Pupbox comparison, we are grateful. We have reviewed several other products in detail, feel free to check them out;

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.